An Open Access Journal
Table 2 Analysis of 13 papers according to multimodality feature
From: Review of intermodal freight transportation in humanitarian logistics
Short Name | Model | Method | Transshipment point (i.e. mode changes) exist | Objective | Multicommodity ransportation | First transportation mode | Second transportation mode | Disaster type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Abdelgawad and Abdulhai [10] | Evacuation | LP, MIP | No | Min cost Min waiting time | No | Road | Rail | not mentioned |
Adıvar and Mert [11] | Relief supplies routing | LP | Yes | Min cost Max credibility | Yes | Not mentioned | Not mentioned | Flood |
Barbarosoğlu and Arda [12] | Relief supplies routing | Stochastic Programming | Yes | Min cost | Yes | Air | Road | Earthquake |
Clark and Culkin [13] | Relief supplies routing | MIP | No | Min cost | Yes | Air | Road, rail, sea | Earthquake |
Haghani and Oh [14] | Relief supplies routing | Heuristic | Yes | Min cost | Yes | Not mentioned | Not mentioned | All |
Hu [15] | Relief supplies routing | MIP | Yes | Min cost | No | Road | Rail, sea | Not mentioned |
Oh and Haghani [16] | Relief supplies routing | MIP | Yes | Min cost | Yes | Not mentioned | Not mentioned | All |
Özdamar et al. [17] | Relief supplies routing | LP, MIP | Yes | Max delivery | Yes | Air | Road, rail, sea | Natural disasters |
Salmerón and Apte [18] | Relief supplies routing Evacuation | Stochastic Programming, MIP | No | Min expected casualties Min expected unmet transfer population | No | Air | Road | Not mentioned |
Tean [19] | Relief supplies routing | Stochastic Programming, MIP Simulation | No | Max survival rate | No | Air | Road, rail, sea | Earthquake, hurricane |
Vitoriano et al. [20] | Relief supplies routing | Goal Programming | Yes | Min cost Max min reliability | No | Air | Road, rail, sea | Food crisis |
Yi and Kumar [21] | Relief supplies routing Evacuation | MIP | No | Min service delay | Yes | Road | Not mentioned | All |
Zhu et al. [22] | Relief supplies routing | IP | No | Min cost | Yes | Road | Rail | Eartquake, flood, typhoon |