Skip to main content

An Open Access Journal

Table 3 Results of bibliographic source clustering

From: Feature selection and extraction in spatiotemporal traffic forecasting: a systematic literature review

Cluster

1

2

3

Average silhouette width

0,517

0,512

0,530

Cluster size

176

143

74

Clustering variables

 Spatiotemporal model

Top 1

STARIMA

FFNN

FFNN

Top 2

BN

VAR

KNN

Top 3

SVR

TDNN

DL/ARDL

Top 4

VAR

RNN

SVR

 Topological structure

Top 1

Network

Sequential freeway

Sequential arterial

 Number of links

Median

26

7

4

 Conventionally referred as

 

Statistical models for a network topology of medium size

ANN for freeways with small number of links

Various models for arterial roads with small number of links

Target variables

 Year

Median

2015

2011

2014

 Spatial FSE

Top 1

CCF

Up/downstream

Up/downstream

Top 2

Upstream

Upstream

All

Top 3

PCA

All

Upstream

 Temporal FSE

Top 1

Predefined

Predefined

Predefined

Top 2

CCF

Empirical

Empirical

Top 3

Empirical

CCF

CCF