Skip to main content

Table 1 Summary of the available picture fuzzy set-based MCDM approaches

From: Picture fuzzy WASPAS method for selecting last-mile delivery mode: a case study of Belgrade

Author(s) and year Research focus Method MCGDM Application type
Wei [68] Emerging technology commercialization PF Cross-entropy No Illustrative example
Liang et al. [35] Gold mines PF EDAS + ELECTRE III Yes Illustrative example
Wang et al. [64] Energy performance contracting PF MABAC Yes Real-life
Wang et al. [66] Risk evaluation of construction project PF Entropy + VIKOR Yes Real-life
Wei [69] Emerging technology commercialization PF TODIM No Illustrative example
Wei et al. [70] Emerging technology commercialization PF Projection No Illustrative example
Zhang et al. [78] Offshore wind power station location PF RP + TOPSIS Yes Real-life
Ashraf et al. [2] Air quality PF TOPSIS Yes Illustrative example
Ju et al. [27] Electric vehicle charging station location Fuzzy AHP + PF GRP Yes Real-life
Liang et al. [34] Gold mines PF TODIM + ELECTRE Yes Real-life
Liu et al. [36] Emerging technology commercialization PF GRA No Illustrative example
Meksavang et al. [38] Beef supply chain PF VIKOR Yes Illustrative example
Sindhu et al. [51] LP + PF TOPSIS No Illustrative example
Torun and Gördebil [60] Satisfaction level PF TOPSIS No Real-life
Zhang et al. [77] Green supplier selection PF EDAS Yes Illustrative example
Joshi [25] Personnel and investment selection PF Entropy + VIKOR Yes Illustrative examples
Tian and Peng [57] Tourism attraction recommendation PF ANP + TODIM Yes Illustrative example
Tian et al. [58] Tourism attraction recommendation PF AHP + PROMETHEE II Yes Illustrative example
Wang et al. [65] Hotel selection PF TODIM Yes Real-life
Yue [73] Software reliability PF VIKOR Yes Illustrative example
Our study Last-mile delivery mode selection PF WASPAS Yes Real-life
  1. GRA Grey Relational Analysis, GRP Grey Relational Projection, LP Linear Programming, MCGDM Multi-Criteria Group Decision-Making, PF Picture Fuzzy, RP Relative Projection